A patient sits across from me, asking about peptides for muscle recovery and anti-aging. “I’ve been reading about BPC-157 and CJC-1295,” he says. “My training partner swears by them. Can you prescribe these?”
This is the moment where medicine intersects with ethics, performance, and enhancement.
And honestly? These conversations are getting more common—and more complicated.
The Rise of Peptide Therapy: Promise and Pitfalls
Peptides are short chains of amino acids that can signal specific cellular responses. Some, like insulin, are well-established medications. Others—like growth hormone secretagogues, tissue repair peptides, and longevity compounds—exist in a medical gray zone.
They’re not FDA-approved for many of the uses patients request them for. They’re often sourced from compounding pharmacies with variable quality control. And yet, they’re increasingly popular in performance medicine, regenerative health, and longevity optimization.
Here’s the ethical dilemma:
As a physician, I took an oath to “first, do no harm.” But what does that mean when a patient is asking for something that might help them—even if it’s not FDA-approved for that specific use?
Do I say no and watch them order it online from an unregulated source?
Or do I engage with the request, educate them, and potentially prescribe it under informed consent?
The answer isn’t black and white. But I believe physicians have a responsibility to meet patients where they are—not where we wish they’d be.
What Patients Are Really Asking For
When someone asks about peptides, they’re rarely asking about the molecule itself. They’re asking:
“Can I recover faster from my workouts?”
“Can I heal this nagging injury that won’t go away?”
“Can I slow down aging?”
“Can I feel like myself again?”
These are legitimate health concerns. And dismissing them with “that’s not FDA-approved” or “just eat better and exercise” misses the point.
Patients aren’t looking for permission to be reckless. They’re looking for a physician who understands that optimization is a valid health goal—not just disease management.
The Physician’s Responsibility: Harm Reduction vs. Prohibition
Here’s where I diverge from some of my colleagues.
I don’t believe my job is to prohibit patients from pursuing performance and longevity interventions. I believe my job is to educate, guide, and reduce harm.
If a patient is determined to use peptides, I’d rather:
- Ensure they’re sourcing them from a reputable compounding pharmacy
- Monitor their labs for safety (kidney function, hormone levels, inflammatory markers)
- Educate them on proper dosing, timing, and realistic expectations
- Help them understand what’s evidence-based vs. anecdotal
- Create a plan that integrates peptides with lifestyle optimization—not as a replacement for it
This is harm reduction medicine. And in my opinion, it’s more ethical than turning a blind eye.
Where I Draw the Line
That said, I’m not a “prescription vending machine.”
I won’t prescribe peptides to someone who:
- Hasn’t optimized their lifestyle first (sleep, nutrition, training, stress)
- Has unrealistic expectations (“I want to look like a bodybuilder in 3 months”)
- Is using them to mask deeper health issues (hormonal dysfunction, metabolic disease)
- Refuses to do baseline labs or follow-up monitoring
- Is seeking them purely for aesthetics without understanding the risks
Enhancement medicine isn’t about shortcuts. It’s about optimization after the fundamentals are in place.
The Bigger Question: What Do Doctors Owe Patients?
This isn’t just about peptides. It’s about a fundamental question in modern medicine:
Do physicians exist to enforce guidelines and protect institutions?
Or do we exist to serve patients—even when their goals don’t fit neatly into FDA-approved boxes?
I believe we owe patients:
- Honesty about what we know and don’t know
- Education about risks, benefits, and alternatives
- Judgment-free conversations about their health goals
- Guidance that prioritizes their safety and well-being
- The autonomy to make informed decisions about their own bodies
We don’t owe them:
- Blind approval of every request
- Prescriptions without proper evaluation
- False promises about outcomes
- Complicity in reckless behavior
The role of a physician in performance and longevity medicine is to be a knowledgeable guide—not a gatekeeper or a cheerleader.
What This Means at Prime Vitality
At Prime Vitality Total Wellness & Medical Spa, we specialize in performance and longevity medicine—including peptide therapy.
But we don’t just hand out prescriptions.
We start with:
- Comprehensive lab work (metabolic panel, hormone levels, inflammatory markers, nutrient status)
- Lifestyle optimization (sleep, nutrition, training, stress management)
- Honest conversations about goals, risks, and realistic timelines
- Personalized treatment plans that integrate evidence-based interventions
- Ongoing monitoring and adjustments
Because peptides aren’t magic. They’re tools. And like any tool, they work best when used correctly—and in the right hands.
Final Thoughts: The Ethics of Enhancement
The future of medicine isn’t just about treating disease. It’s about optimization.
And as physicians, we need to decide: Are we going to be part of that conversation? Or are we going to let patients navigate it alone?
I choose to be part of it.
Not because I want to be “cutting-edge” or “trendy.”
But because I believe patients deserve physicians who meet them where they are—with education, safety, and respect.
If you’re interested in performance medicine, peptide therapy, or longevity optimization, schedule a consultation with us. Let’s have an honest conversation about your goals—and whether enhancement medicine is right for you.
Dr. Shiv Kumar Goel is a board-certified internal medicine physician and founder of Prime Vitality Total Wellness & Medical Spa, specializing in functional medicine, hormone optimization, and performance medicine.
Ready to Optimize Your Health with Expert Guidance?
If you’re considering peptide therapy, hormone optimization, or performance medicine, don’t navigate it alone.
At Prime Vitality Total Wellness & Medical Spa, we provide:
✓ Comprehensive lab analysis and metabolic assessment
✓ Evidence-based peptide therapy protocols
✓ Personalized treatment plans tailored to your goals
✓ Ongoing monitoring and medical supervision
✓ Honest, judgment-free consultations
Schedule Your Consultation Today
Whether you’re an athlete looking to optimize recovery, a professional seeking longevity strategies, or someone ready to take control of your health—we’re here to help.
Call us: +1 (210) 876-1635
Visit:https://primevitalitycare.com
Book online: Schedule your consultation
Let’s have an honest conversation about your health goals and create a personalized plan that works for you.